B2.5. Fluency
Reading fluency is multifaceted: to fluently read text, students must have automaticity with foundational skills, including phonemic awareness, grapheme-phoneme correspondences, and word reading. Students become fluent readers when we explicitly teach all of the sub-skills involved in reading, provide many opportunities for supported practice reading texts out loud, and provide timely feedback and support.
Fluency plays a significant role in students’ comprehension and motivation to read (Hasbrouck, 2020), and because of this, explicitly teaching students to read accurately, at a good rate, and with appropriate expression should be integrated into everyday literacy instruction.
In Grade 2, you will really start to notice that students’ fluency grows quickly with the appropriate instruction and support.
During Grade 1, the focus was on:
- Accurate and automatic grapheme-phoneme correspondence
- Accurate and effortless word identification at the single-word level, based on learned grapheme-phoneme correspondence and explicitly taught irregular words
- Reading decodable texts aloud with accuracy and appropriate pacing
New for Grade 2:
- Reading a variety of text with accuracy and appropriate pacing
- Using decoding strategies to work through new words
- Recoding (rereading) newly decoded words to increase word reading fluency
- Using knowledge of punctuation to support phrasing
- Reading with intonation and expression
Note: This is not an exhaustive list of all expectations in this strand. For a more detailed view, please see the official Ontario curriculum.
Why is fluency important?
Reading fluency is considered the bridge between two essential components of reading – word reading and comprehension. This relationship is reciprocal:
- A fluent reader can decode text automatically and can focus their attention on comprehending what they read (Pikulski & Chard, 2005).
- In the nonfluent reader, weak word recognition slows the process and uses resources needed for comprehension (National Reading Panel, 2000).
- Students who score lower on fluency also score lower on comprehension (Jenkins et al., 2003).
- Reading fluency, especially prosody, depends on comprehension. For example, to read a text with appropriate expression, students need to be able to understand the text first (Groen et al., 2018).
Oral Reading Fluency Measures
The mandatory reading screening for Grade 2 includes a timed measure of Oral Reading Fluency. This is a quick one-minute assessment that measures how many words a student can read correctly in a minute. While this assessment may be new and may seem less thorough than the running record assessments we may have used in the past, these measures are more accurate and efficient.
If you are curious about why we are shifting away from reading levels and moving toward these shorter fluency measures, please take a moment to read Reconsidering Reading Levels.
For students who are flagged at risk during screening, you can use our Making Sense of Screening Decision Tree to identify areas that need further assessment and intervention.
Explicit Fluency Instruction
For all students, you can incorporate daily routines that support fluency development. Here are a some important components of effective repeated reading instruction:
1. Set a Goal:
It is helpful to set goals for students to increase the number of words read correctly per minute by 10% from the initial read to the final read. Consider sharing these goals with students. Students knowing their goals and tracking their progress can be very motivating.
2. Modeling:
Students do better when they hear a skilled model of the text prior to repeated reading. The model can be done by the teacher, a more skilled peer, or on audio recording (this is often referred to in the intervention literature as listening passage preview).
3. Practice:
“Students do best when they reread the same section of a passage five times, although rereading three times also has been shown to be effective.” (Stollar, 2020). The primary focus for all readers should be accuracy first. Once accuracy is achieved, additional goals focused on pace and/or expression can be integrated into the fluency work.
4. Corrective Feedback:
Students do better when they have goals and error correction. It is helpful for the teacher or peer to supply the word after an error or three second hesitation. Practicing decoding words that are read incorrectly also improves the effectiveness of repeated reading.
5. Strategic Partners:
Students who practice with a teacher make more improvement than those who practice with a peer. Using a peer who is a stronger reader is equally as effective as using a peer at the same reading level.
Oral Reading Routines
Repeated reading is a well-researched instructional routine with a series of timed reads, but practicing oral reading can be used across the day with a variety of texts, including within content areas. See the table below for some examples of ways to mix up oral reading with your students.
Choral Reading
Everyone reads together (usually after the teacher has modeled / gone through the text with students).
Echo Reading
The teacher reads a sentence/line/stanza, and then the student(s) reread the same text directly after, chorally.
Whisper Reading
Students whisper read while the teacher reads, tracking with their finger.
Cloze Reading
The teacher reads a text and pauses at certain words, students then read the missing word chorally.
Pattern Reading
The teacher reads a line/sentence, the students read a line/sentence, and they flip back and forth.
Partner Reading
Students paired strategically. The stronger reader (reader A) reads for a set amount of time or text. The weaker reader (reader B) follows along. When the time/passage is up, reader B rereads the same text that reader A just read. Then they switch roles.
Additional details available here.
Cross-Curricular Connections: (linked to A3 strand)
Good instruction is integrated instruction! Fluency can be taught and practiced through reading across content areas. As part of your science teaching, use AI to write some short theatre scripts or poems from the point of view of various animals, explaining how they are being impacted by human activities. After engaging in explicit teaching using a repeated reading routine, have students practice the scripts or poems until they are ready to present them to an audience. Extension: Have students problem-solve various ways that the negative impacts can be minimized.
Curriculum Connections:
- Grade 2 Science: B1 Strand
- Grade 2 Language: B1, B2, C1
- Grade 2 Drama: B1 Strand
A Note About Silent Reading: Although silent reading can have many positive benefits for students who are fluent readers, including increasing vocabulary and knowledge, there are several drawbacks that teachers need to be aware of as they decide when, where, and if silent reading is right for their students. These potential drawbacks to silent reading may include:
- Students ‘fake reading’ and just look at pictures, flipping the pages – this could be due to lack of engagement, and/or a lack of reading skills
- Assessment challenges – in order to know if students are reading fluently, educators need to hear students read aloud
- Missed learning opportunities – without guidance, feedback, or interaction, silent reading may not address the individual needs of each student, potentially leaving behind those who require more structured support
Further Reading
- Reading Road Trip: All Things Fluency with Dr. Jan Hasbrouck (podcast)
- How Effective is Independent Reading in Teaching Reading (Shanahan, 2018) (blog post)
- For Students Who Are Not Yet Fluent, Silent Reading Is Not the Best Use of Classroom Time (Hasbrouck, 2006) (article)
- ONlit: Fluency Overview (webpage)
- Focused Oral Reading Practice: A New Approach (PaTTAN, 2022) (video)